Friday, August 13, 2010

Directors Series Wrap-Up

OK, so the countdown did not conclude with the exact scenario that I would have chosen, but all in all I still found it to be one of the most rewarding series that I have done in the history of the blog. Perhaps it was not as time-consuming or as in-depth as some of the other countdowns, but it was every bit as difficult to make the list and then to try and rank sometimes massive bodies of work. Still, it was fun for me to do. As everyone who follows the blog knows, I am the type of cineaste that takes great pleasure in re-watching favorites. Sometimes, this works to my detriment, as I re-watch films two and three times at the expense of finally getting to the piles of movies that are waiting to be viewed for the first time. But it works perfectly for an exercise like a favorite directors series, as it was an excuse to go back and watch some all-time favorites.

As for this post, I at least wanted to conclude the series as I have all of the other countdowns with a wrap-up post that ties everything together. As I said from the start, the list would have a slant/bias toward American or English-language directors. This is not because I have anything against world cinema, it's just natural that I would give high positions to what I am more familiar with. Thus, 26 of the 30 directors in the countdown worked in Hollywood at some point in their careers. A number of them were born outside of the United States, and did significant work in Europe, but eventually came to the States and found great success. Perhaps this statistic just shows how little I know about cinema in general, but I make no apologies. Everyone on this list is a master and deserves such recognition. As I continue to become familiar with more and more directors (particularly from around the world), they might knock many of these Americans out of such a list. Until then, I stand by my choices and love the work of each director.

What I thought would be most interesting would be to throw up the names of a dozen directors who I painfully was forced to keep out of the Top 30, along with give a brief thought or explanation on their films or why I didn't include them. Although these aren't really in any particular order, the first name on the list was the hardest one to decide what to do with:

-David Lynch: There were times when I thought Lynch would push for the Top 15. Others, as ultimately happened, I wasn't sure I would even include him. The problem I have with forming an overall opinion of Lynch's work is how I tend to respond to his films. He has a few that I absolutely love and think are masterpieces - Mulholland Drive and Lost Highway. But there are others that I flat out dislike - Dune, Wild at Heart, Inland Empire. Even my high regard of Twin Peaks has tempered somewhat. So there is very little middle ground, although Blue Velvet has recently begun to click for me. So basically, it's a very hot-or-cold relationship I have with Lynch, making it very hard to place him in the context of a Top 30. So, I eventually opted to have him just on the outside looking in.

-Michael Curtiz: This would have a been a surprising selection I am sure, but it very nearly happened. And thinking about it now, I easily could have included Curtiz at least at #29 or #30. He might not have the most impressive overall body of work, but he made my favorite movie of the 1930s (Angels With Dirty Faces) and my first or second favorite film of the 1940s (Casablanca). After those two films, though, there is a drop off, with Mildred Pierce being the only other Curtiz film that really does a whole lot for me. Still. those top two are so strong that he very nearly made the list.

-Quentin Tarantino: Similar to the situation I described with David Lynch, I tend to have a hot-or-cold relationship with Tarantino. I still firmly believe that his first two films, Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction, are miles and miles ahead of anything else he has ever done. I also enjoy Jackie Brown and have recently come around on Iglourious Basterds, but those few in between do nothing for me. The Kill Bill series I have trouble even taking seriously and Death Proof doesn't really thrill me. In initial drafts of my list Tarantino was included, and in looking at things now he probably makes as a strong a case for me as Spielberg or Ray, but I ultimately sided with the two who have more movies that I enjoy.

-Jacques Becker: It is hard not to take into account the small body of work that I have seen from Becker, but this didn't bar him from the list - after all, I also included Jacques Tati. Still, loving only two films from a director makes it hard to rank him over the other giants he was up against. Even so, I still maintain that Touchez pas au grisbi is one of if not the best French gangster films ever made.

-Jules Dassin: Shockingly enough, Dassin was initially a lock for the list. But when I went to make my rankings of his films, I found that I have a Big Four for him and that's it. Rififi, Brute Force and Night and the City are three of the finest noirs and films of an era. Thieves' Highway is also excellent, even if I consider slightly below the other three. Outside of those, I'm not really a fan of much else. I know that many folks consider The Naked City to be a great film but I have never been a fan. Even so, I still consider myself a huge Dassin fan and cherish those four favorites.

-Raoul Walsh: I feel like I still need to see more Walsh, which might have factored into him not being included. What I have seen though are great ones. The Roaring Twenties remains one of my favorite gangster films and in my opinion one of the best of the '30s. The reputation of White Heat speaks for itself. High Sierra is wonderful. Walsh seems to remain something of an overlooked director - everyone recognizes his work, but few think of him for lists like this.

-William Wyler:: Another classic Hollywood director that sometimes gets lumped in with being a "studio director" but who nonetheless made a number of exceptional films. What might have held him back from the list is that aside from my two favorites - The Best Years of Our Lives and The Letter - the rest of his work remains around the "consistently above average" level. By this I mean that they are very, very good films, but not quite great.

-Sergio Leone: Another odd one to rank, as he made two all-time favorites with Once Upon a Time in the West and Once Upon a Time in America, then a number of films that I just like. The Man With No Name trilogy has a staggering reputation, but I've never really connected with them as so many others have.

-Carol Reed: I've seen a small number of Carol Reed films, but they remain impressive. The The Fallen Idol and The Third Man are an impressive back-to-back combination.

-Joseph L. Mankiewicz: Another studio director that isn't immediately considered for lists like this, but I still love this writer-director's work. All About Eve remains my favorite, but the list of other impressive credits shows his consistency. House of Strangers, Somewhere in the Night, The Barefoot Contessa, The Ghost and Mrs. Muir, Julius Caesar - all very solid work, some at least bordering on great.

-Akira Kurosawa: My guess is that Kurosawa would have been a lock for most list from everyone else. In a "greatest directors" series, he certainly would have made mine. I certainly appreciate his craft and recognize the talent. But since this is a "favorites" series, and Kurosawa is not a director I consistently reach for when I just want to sit back and enjoy a movie, I opted not to include him. This shouldn't be taken as disliking Kurosawa though. I love Ran, Throne of Blood, and High and Low. If I sometimes have trouble connecting to samurai films, it still doesn't detract from appreciating the overall craftsmanship and storytelling.

-Bernardo Bertolucci: I think so highly of The Conformist (a Top 10 all-time film for me) that I nearly catapulted Bertolucci into the ranks on that alone. Obviously that didn't happen, but I still gave him strong consideration. What probably kept him out is that The Conformist is _so_ far out in front of anything else he has ever made, it just didn't feel like the overall body of work could overtake those I included on the list.


  1. A number of these of course would quality for the lists of many, and I can certainly see (in each instance) what stopped you from including them on the Top 30. As always it always a situation where you might think otherwise tomorrow.

  2. A very interesting list, Dave. Also it's quite fun for me to see how your tastes and interests have evolved over the past two years. It seems you have started to much more appreciate the older works and film history in general, as you have chosen Keaton, Chaplin, Powell & Pressburger (of whom I still haven't seen anything), Sturges, Lubitsch and Dreyer. None of these I had expected to find on your list, although they all are very important to cinema.

    Now, I have to ask you a few questions about directors not included in your list/honourable mentions.

    What about Jean Renoir? I found it a bit strange that considering your unexpected choices, you have not saved a spot for Renoir. Is there a reason for this? I realise it is a favourite list as opposed to a greatest list, but wouldn't you say he deserves a spot in a Top 30 either way? He does for me, as he is one of the few directors I have an absolutely emotional connection with. Other classical directors and poetic realists like Ford and Kurosawa you did mention, but I find Renoir's films to be much in that same vein; different only in style of origin: him being French, Kurosawa being Japanese and Ford being American. Anything you might want to say about this?

    And the same goes for films by Satiyajit Ray, although I can't blame you for not mentioning him as his films are not quite as widely seen as the others I mentioned.

    Another one I thought I'd encounter, which I haven't, is Samuel Fuller.Now we all know Fuller's a weird little man, but his style which is so out there, a real anti-Hollywood within Hollywood itself it seems. I personally would not add him to my personal list (which I will post here later, when I've worked out an order), but I kind of expected to see him mentioned here. Maybe I'm totally mistaken, but I always thought you'd have really dug his style.

  3. not quite as thought-through as your own, but here's a Top 30 for the time being :)
    I have also included my favourite of each filmmaker...
    1. Akira Kurosawa (Ran)
    2. Alfred Hitchcock (Vertigo)
    3. Stanley Kubrick (2001 – A Space Odyssey)
    4. John Ford (Stagecoach)
    5. Billy Wilder (Sunset Blvd.)
    6. Francis Ford Coppola (Apocalypse Now)
    7. Jean Renoir (La Regle Du Jeu)
    8. Frank Capra (It’s A Wonderful Life)
    9. Martin Scorsese (Taxi Driver)
    10. Orson Welles (Citizen Kane)
    11. Paul Thomas Anderson (Magnolia)
    12. Robert Altman (Nashville)
    13. Joel & Ethan Coen (The Big Lebowski)
    14. Charlie Chaplin (The Great Dictator)
    15. Woody Allen (Annie Hall)
    16. Sergio Leone (The Good, The Bad & The Ugly)
    17. David Lynch (Blue Velvet)
    18. Sidney Lumet (Network)
    19. Jean-Luc Godard (Pierrot Le Fou)
    20. Fritz Lang (The Big Heat)
    21. Roman Polanski (Chinatown)
    22. Andrei Tarkovsky (Stalker)
    23. Max Ophuls (Letter From An Unknown Woman)
    24. Steven Spielberg (Schindler’s List)
    25. Anthony Mann (Raw Deal)
    26. Nicholas Ray (Rebel Without A Cause)
    27. Kryzstof Kieslowski (Blanc)
    28. Quentin Tarantino (Pulp Fiction)
    29. David Lean (Lawrence Of Arabia)
    30. John Carpenter (Assault On Precinct 13)

    What do you think?

  4. Congratulations on completing this, Dave - as with your other countdowns, I have enjoyed following it and reading all the postings and comments even though I've only chimed in now and then. The postings will be a great resource to go back to in future as I see more by the directors.

    I'm pleased to see Michael Curtiz and Raoul Walsh mentioned in your "nearlies" as they are both directors I like very much, though I need to see more of their work. I'm a fan of quite a few Curtiz films apart from the three greats you mention - I also like 'The Adventures of Robin Hood' 'Yankee Doodle Dandy', 'Flamingo Road' (though others might not agree with me on that one as it is rather melodramatic!)and the Bogart film 'Passage to Marseille', among others. For Walsh I love all the three you mention, plus two more he made with Cagney, 'The Strawberry Blonde' and 'A Lion is in the Streets', and 'They Drive By Night' with Bogart. Looking at the imdb, both of these directors had amazingly long careers, with Curtiz's running from 1912 to 1961 and taking in more than 170 films, and Walsh's running from 1913 to 1964 with nearly 140 films.

  5. You missed one of Michael Curtiz's best -
    BREAKING POINT - with John Garfield. Based on Hemmingway's To Have & Have Not. Hemingway said it was his favorite adaption.
    Garfield in his prime - and Wallace Ford sweating up a storm. Great flick.

  6. hey tommorello , I liked your list of filmmakers. Out of them, Billy Wilder (Sunset Blvd.),
    Martin Scorsese (Taxi Driver), and
    Joel & Ethan Coen are my favorite ones..

  7. It's been a while since I last checked in, but I'm happy to see you completed this great endeavour! Now, I haven't seen enough films in my lifetime to come up with a relevant top 30, but we do have a bunch of favorite directors in common, namely Tati, Allen, Kubrick, Keaton, the Coens, Melville, Chaplin and most importantly Scorsese, Wilder and Hitch who would most likely constitute my top 3 as well.

    Anyway, well done sir, it was a pleasure to read!

  8. thought I'd encounter, which I haven't, is Samuel Fuller.Now we all know Fuller's a weird little man

  9. Great Conversation ! Thanks for post. Find out lot of new things here. Thank you very much..

  10. I take my hat off to the author of this article. Well done.

  11. Goodfella, where are you?
    Come back, we miss you.

  12. Waiting for Goodfella to come back.

  13. free old movie downloads!!!

  14. Wow, thanks for compiling the list of outstanding movie directors. I like the films of William Wyler.

  15. Great ....knowledge and work good to interpret and understand

  16. i like quentin tarantino movies, for me he got his own style

  17. Anyone know what happened to Dave? I used to love this blog in its heyday, sad to see it remain inactive...

  18. I guess he has better things to do now than be here with us the fans.

  19. Ten greatest directors?

    Orson Welles
    Stanley Kubrick
    Sergei Eisenstein
    Kenji Mizoguchi
    Fritz Lang
    Alfred Hitchcock
    Carl Dreyer
    Steven Spielberg (Not a deep thinker but a fabulous showman)
    Alain Resnais
    Kon Ichikawa

  20. Wonderful story, It is really nice thanks for sharing this wonderful post

  21. Nice Technical Information. I hope everybody lick this Post.

  22. I didn't see any of the post after 2010. If you have posted, we have got many information.
    Thanks for sharing.

    get more instagram followers

  23. Most old movies are being remake because they are so good even if the CGI effects are not that good.

  24. Hello Readers! If you’re looking for the best Funny Memes For Facebook (Fb) DP, Whatsapp status then I must say you’re at the right place. Visit our website and get the Baisakhi funny images Wishes and Learn coronavirus precautions, and 5 April lighting Night in India.




  28. Great post. I found helpful information in this article.Thank you xnxx

  29. Your blog is so beautiful, I have been so busy lately about life but let me share with you all about my health life experience with the great herbal traditional doctor that saved the life of mine and my dear husband.
    I was suffering from a deadly disease herpes and diabetes and i went through alot trying to get better each everyday of my life until I came across a testimony on blogs someone telling good about Dr Jekawo, a traditional herbal doctor that cure all kind of disease such as: herpes,diabetes,epilepsy,cancer,hpv,lupus,degenerative disease,shingles,erectile dysfunction also bring back ex,leukemia,fibroid and other spiritual consultations, I contacted him via then he prepared the herbal medicines and send to me which takes 21 days treatment that cured my diabetes and herpes completely,I'm so grateful with the help he rendered to me therefore I promised to share his great works.
    Thank you and I hope this could save someone else out there.
    Karen Paul
    South Carolina.