Sunday, November 15, 2009

2002: City of God (Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund)

Released: August 30, 2002

a.k.a.: Cidade de Deus

Directors: Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund; Screenplay: Braulio Mantovani based on the novel “Cidade de Deus” by Paulo Lins; Cinematography: Cesar Charlone; Studios: 02 Filmes, Globo Filmes, StudioCanal, and Wild Bunch; Producers: Andrea Barata Ribeiro, Mauricio Andrade Ramos, Elisa Tolomelli, and Walter Salles

Cast: Alexandre Rodrigues (adult Rocket), Luis Otavio (child Rocket), Leando Firmino de Hora (Li’l Zé), Douglas Silva (Li’l Dice), Phellipe Haagensen (adult Benny), Michel de Souza (child Benny), Matheus Nachtergaele (Carrot), Seu Jorge (Knockout Ned), Jonathan Haagensen (Shaggy), Renato de Souza (Goose), Jefechander Suplino (Clipper), Edson Oliveira (adult Stringy), Ermerson Gomes (child Stringy), Alice Braga (Angelica), Daniel Zettel (Tiago), Darlan Cunha (Steak with Fries), Charles Paraventi (Uncle Sam), Graziella Moretto (Marina Cintra), Luiz Carlos Ribeiro (Bull), Mauricio Marques (Big Head)

Not many things in cinema are able to appall me. Sure, there are moments in films that might startle me or make me nervous. Or even passages of films that stick with me long after a movie ends, which I continually think about or grapple with. Rarely do I see something on screen that actually makes me uneasy to the point that I want to look away, particularly in regards to violence. Perhaps I’m just too desensitized to the point that such things don’t have great impact on me. Even more likely, I think I’m able to put what I’m seeing into context, which makes it much more palatable – in other words, I’m not horrified by the violence in Goodfellas, because I know what such a life, and movie, entails. But one particular scene in City of God managed to make me squirm. When a kid, aspiring to become a neighborhood hoodlum, is forced to choose which of two young boys to shoot in order to prove his mettle, it was hard for me to even watch the scene. The skill with which the scene was directed, the tension created by the script, it all comes together perfectly – you react to it as I did, “horribly” in a good way. That scene is seared into my mind, the one image I can’t shake from this incredible account of life in the slums of Rio de Janeiro.

Certainly a great film is not found in a single scene, but for me it undercuts the key criticism that is leveled against City of God: the fact that it retreads a lot of ground that has been covered in previous crime films. To be certain, the influences of American crime dramas are obvious – the realistic, documentary feel of Martin Scorsese’s early works, the quirkiness and sometimes humorous episodic structure of a Tarantino film, the childhood to adulthood scope of countless gangster films. I’ve seen some claim that the only difference is setting the film in the favela of Brazil. Maybe this is true, but it glosses over what an enormous variation this is. Exploring an underworld that most viewers know very little about, it looks at issues of crime and life in the ghetto differently than any of the previously mentioned films. And in the end, its answers, or lack thereof, are no easier to digest than the scene I described in the first paragraph.

The technically dazzling opening sequence sets the overall theme of the movie, as the main character Rocket (Alexandre Rodrigues) finds himself literally caught in a standoff – old comrades from the Cidade de Deus slums where he grew up on one side, the state police on the other. Rocket grew up in the favela (roughly translating as "slum") in the 1960s, but always remained on the fringes of criminal activity. He sees his brother Goose (Renato de Souza), part of a legendary gang called the “Tender Trio” along with partners in crime Shaggy (Jonathan Haagensen) and Clipper (Jefechander Suplino), lose his life over menial street crime. Instead, Rocket concentrates on school as best he can while growing up in the ghetto, following more carefree pursuits like his crush on the gorgeous Angelica (Alice Braga) and smoking the occasional joint with friends. Moving into the 70s, Rocket remains on the fringes of crime, hanging out with others that are involved in the rampant drug trade, but never becoming directly involved himself. Instead, he focuses on his dream of becoming a photographer, working odd jobs in order to earn enough cash to purchase his own first-rate equipment.

Such noble pursuits are rare in the City of God, however, as most boys grow up idolizing the drug dealers and hoodlums that control the area. The prime example of this is Li’l Dice (Douglas Silva), a boy who followed the Tender Trio around like a mascot. With a quick temper and unmatched bloodlust, by the time he is eighteen he is running a large part of the City of God. Rechristening himself Li’l Zé (Leando Firmino de Hora), he teams up with best friend Benny (Phellipe Haagensen) and sets his sights on taking over the drug trade in the entire ghetto. This inevitably leads to clashes with other drug dealers, as they battle for turf. Li’l Zé's first reaction to any resistance is to kill everyone who opposes them. But Benny is the mild-mannered partner, the only one who can calm his pal. Eventually tension begins to build even between the two friends, as Benny drifts away from a life of crime and falls in love with Angelica.

There are other sub-strands to the story that really make the Cidade de Deus favela come alive. Even minor characters have personality and colorful names. Carrot, the local drug dealer who rises to prominence through his persistence and loyalty to previous bosses. The decade-long history of the apartment that once served as his headquarters is told quickly and adeptly. Things like the neighborhood bar owner who is a dry snitch for local police who snaps when he catches his wife in bed with Goose. And the bus driver and karate expert everyone knows as Knockout Ned. Or the gang of “groovies” that Rocket begins to hang out with in his adolescence. Or the group of young “Runts,” kids in their pre-teens who terrorize the streets and local shop owners while mimicking the gangsters that they idolize. Really, the city itself is given such personality that it almost serves as a character in its own right. The City of God and its inhabitants truly come alive and it is the one constant throughout everything.

For a movie so brutal, very little of the violence is directly shown. There isn’t a lot in the way of blood and gore. But it in no way lessens the impact. The amazing thing is how natural it all is, how characters don’t seem to even give it a second thought. Even Benny, the one hood with a heart in the entire story, utilizes gunplay and violence when needed. He uses it sparingly in comparison to someone like Li’l Zé, but even so called “good guys” are drawn toward it at some point. Rocket even takes a gun at one point in time with plans to knock off a local bus driver for cash. Plans like this are ordinary to the teenagers in the city, even ones who don’t consider themselves criminals. The violence is particularly hard to stomach when it involves kids, which is quite often. And by “kids” I don’t mean teenagers, I mean actual kids. As in nine or ten year-olds toting guns and shooting former playmates. I’ve also seen complaints about the high body count, with the endless barrage of killings and the complete lack of caring at the deaths. Again, I think such critics are completely missing the point. It’s _supposed_ to get this reaction out of you. The fact that kids, teenagers and others are executed and nobody seems to care is one of the key statements of the film. It reiterates the fact that these killings are all too common and that it’s a vicious cycle taking place – one kid is brutally murdered, another steps right in to take his place. There’s no time to stop and mourn or analyze why it happened. The drug trade and violence continues.

The direction from Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund is as stylish as it gets, displaying technical chops and innovative camera work throughout. I already mentioned the opening sequence that is dazzling, but such technique really is on display over the course of the entire movie. There is much handheld camera work in following characters through the streets of the City of God, lending it any almost neorealist feel. What amazes me is how Meirelles and Lund are able to capture such a hip, stylish visual style while at the same time retaining the gritty, Mean Streets-like feel of the story. Also adding to this neorealist feeling is the fact that a majority of the actors were not professionals, but rather were found in real-life Brazilian favelas and cast into the film. That is incredible to me consider how smooth many of the performances are, particularly from all of the kids.

I won’t go as far as some who declare City of God to be on par with previous crime epics like The Godfather or Goodfellas, but it’s unfair for almost any other movie to be compared to those. I do think it’s a great film, portraying a city and a struggle that most people don’t often get to see. Plus, after taking Portuguese in college, this was the first foreign film I was ever able to watch and actually somewhat understand without subtitles. That’s got to be worth something, right?!

Rating: 9/10

Other Contenders for 2002: Although I don’t usually think of 2002 as a banner year, looking at it now I realize that there are many, many outstanding films. As is the case with most of the 2000s, my exposure is primarily to American cinema, but this year I am actually somewhat well-rounded. Aside from City of God, there are others from around the world that I have to acknowledge. Yimou Zhang’s Hero is another entry on that short list of martial arts films that I like. Aleksandr Sokurov’s Russian Ark is unlike anything else I’ve ever seen, or for that matter even heard of, but it’s incredibly fascinating. The whole approach is innovative and it’s surprising that anyone is able to pull it off this well. And finally, the exiled Roman Polanski’s The Pianist. While I don’t rank it as highly as many others, it’s still a masterful production from Polanski.

As for American cinema, favorites also abound. While I did not initially care much for Sam Mendes’ Road to Perdition, I’ve seen done a complete 180. The cinematography is gorgeous, on a near Malickian level (yes, I’m making that word up). It might now be my favorite Mendes film. I also have always been of the opinion that all three of the Lord of the Rings trilogy are basically on equal footing in terms of quality, so I have to include The Two Towers. The others I might not personally put on the same level as these two, but I also really like: Far From Heaven (Todd Haynes), Catch Me If You Can (Steven Spielberg), Adaptation (Spike Jonze).


  1. Wonderful review Dave. There is, as you say, a heavy influence of American mainstream over here. But I guess teh film is far from reality, as Slumdog Millionaire is. It should be considered no more seriously than, say, Indiana Jones or Jaws.

    BTW, the docu "Bus 174", of the same year, is like a companion to this film. Hope you check that out. That's even better, I would say.

    My favs:

    Adaptation. (Jonze)
    Gangs Of New York (Scorsese)
    Minority Report (Spielberg)
    Catch Me If You Can (Spielberg)
    Panic Room (Fincher)
    Road To Perdition (Mendes)
    Signs (Shyamalan)
    The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (Jackson)
    Bowling For Columbine (Moore)
    City of God (Meirelles)
    I’m a Born Liar (Pettigrew)
    Talk To Her Almodovar)
    Bus 174 (Padilha, Lacerda)
    The Way Home… (Lee)
    The Clay Bird (Masud)
    Mr. And Mrs. Iyer (Sen)
    Ten (Kiarostami)
    The Pianist (polanski)
    Hero (Yimou)

  2. Paste mag calls City of God as the movie of the decade:

  3. Outstanding work here Dave, and certainly a film that I've always felt stands amoung the best of 2002, which is arguably the best year of the 2000s in film. Yes,I must agree that teh scene where the kid must choose which of the two boys to kill to prove his mettle is appalling and deeply disturbing. It is indeed amazing that so much of the violence is seenoff screen. But a testament to its influence is the inevitable slew of imitations in style that followed.

    My own #1 film of this year, which I have ceaselessly promoted and saw over 20 times in the movie theatre, is to this point my #1 film of the decade. Almodovar's greatest film, the deeply-moving TALK TO HER and the spectacular musical, CHICAGO are the greatest of the long runners-up list.

    My Own #1 Film of 2002:

    Far From Heaven (Haynes; USA)


    Talk To Her (Almodovar; Spain)
    Chicago (Marshall; USA)
    The Hours (Daldry; USA/UK)
    The Quiet American (Noyce; USA)
    10 (Kiarostami; Iran)
    Spider (Cronenberg; Canada)
    City of God (Meirelles; Brazil)
    The Son (Dardennes; France)
    The Lord of the Rings: Two Towers (Jackson; NZ)
    Distant (Ceylan; Turkey)
    Hero (Yimou; China)
    Waiting For Happiness (Sissako; France/Mauitania)
    The Magdelene Sisters (Mullan; Ireland)
    The Pianist (Polanski; France; Poland)
    Blissfully Yours (Weeasethakul; Thailand)
    Gangs of New York (Scorsese; USA)
    The Isle (Ki-Duk; Korea)
    Catch Me If You Can (Spielberg; USA)
    Mostly Martha (Nettlebeck; Germany)
    The Secret Life of Altar Boys (Care; USA)
    Whale Rider (Caro; NZ)
    Sunshine State (Sayles; USA)
    Road to Perdition (Mendes; USA)
    In America (Sheridan; Ireland/UK)
    Bowling For Columbine (Moore; USA)

    I am not big fan of ADAPTATION, but I respect those who feel otherwise including JAFB and you Dave. ETERNAL SUNSHINE is actually 2003 Dave, but you might have other criteria for having it for this year. It will be my #2 of 2003 in fact.

    Again, a superlative case for this powerful Brazilian film here.

  4. JAFB - Thanks for the compliments. I will definitely check out Bus 174, it definitely sounds like something that I would like.

    Sam - Just an error on my part including Eternal Sunshine, don't know why I added it here. According to IMDB, it actually wasn't even released until 2004, so I was two full years early!

  5. City of God is a good choice. It isn't so much a do-over of American crime films as it is one of a global genre of episodic crime films that includes Amores Perros, Gomorra and others. That may make it seem familiar in retrospect, but I think it retains a power to shock.

    My own favorite is Russian Ark. It is a sort of stunt film, but as such it's also a one-of-a-kind achievement that does have a cumulatively uncanny effect that achieves Sokurov's goal of bringing history to haunting life. And here's the rest.

    2. City of God
    3. LOTR: The Two Towers
    4. The Pianist
    5. Gangs of New York
    6. Ten
    7. Irreversible (Gaspar Noe)
    8. The Hours
    9. Hero
    10.Bubba Ho-Tep (Don Coscarelli)

  6. Samuel - That's a fine summation of City of God's place in the landscape of crime films. And in the end, I don't even mind do-overs so long as they are well made and the story is engrossing. I'm actually glad to see somebody choose Russian Ark as their number one. Like I said, it's unlike anything I've ever seen and for that alone it is impossible not to be interested in what is being attempted.

  7. Well Dave, you got me with another film I have not seen, still a great review and a film I will have to catch up. For me, my # 1 was Polanski's The Pianist

    Far From Heaven
    Gangs of New York
    Minority Report
    About Schmidt

    The Hours
    The Quiet American
    Whale Rider
    The Magdelene Sisters
    Road to Perdition
    Catch Me If You Can

  8. John - This is one that I think you'll like. We have similar tastes in regards to crime dramas, the the influence of some our favorites is obvious in this film.

  9. Another great review Dave. I've heard of this for a long time, but have never sought it out. It sounds right up my alley, so I'll have to make sure I watch it in preparation for any best of the decade lists.

    Oh, and I'll do my best to add "Malickian" to my daily vernacular.

  10. Great review Dave.

    Well, the first thing that I felt once I'd watched the movie was the irony in its title. I guess it should have been, The City that God has Forsaken. Really very few directors have the necessary guts, if you will, to bring out, in such realistic yet heart-wrenching manner, the violent and dark underbelly of a place or city.

    And when I watched Slumdog Millionaire, it was easy to realise where the primary inspiration for the movie lay. Though based on a book, the real template that Danny Boyle used was that of City of God.

  11. Excellent choice for '02, one that I'd actually forgotten about when wondering what your selection would be. That said it's probably one of my top films of the year. I've flipped on it a little bit, wondering if it's too slick for it's own good, but that's the sort of inevitable reaction favorite films always entail - at one point I even reconsidered Mulholland Dr.'s decision to "explain" its dream texture. Usually, I come back to a firm footing on which I can . This one blew me away when I first saw it.

    One of the great things about the movie is, as you put it, the "character" of the city. I'm always fascinated by transformations over time - of people and of places, so the city's gradual transition from barren, almost desert town to overheated, crowded, crumbling ghetto with a million stories never ceases to impress me. I can think of few films which evoke a changing place with the same skill.

    Kudos to JAFB for mentioning Bus 174. I'll echo the sentiment and call that the best film of 2002 as well. Really sad and disturbing and fascinating.

  12. Troy - Please do... maybe we can make "Malickian" a cliche of the movie world! :)

    Shubhajit - I think that's a fair comparison between City of God and Slumdog Millionaire. Although, I still find City of God to be the more powerful (and better) film of the two.

    MovieMan - Sounds like I definitely need to check out Bus 174. It's been added to the always-expanding Netflix queue.

  13. A masterpiece.

    And to think,I watched "Gangs Of New York" with a good friend which was a piece of utter junk, instead of this.

    Even worse,it was made by Martin S.
    Even geniuses can have a bad day.

    "City Of God", along with "Downfall", "13",[.REC], "Hidden" and many, many more is proof there is life outside of Hollywood, and that many foreign films are vastly superior to the laughable drivel that comprises US films today.

  14. Nice post sir . I will followed you
    Thank for post.


  15. Its one of the best movie I have ever watched. Its an excellent movie and will recommend to all to watch it once. The story line is truly amazing and I will rate this movie as excellent.

  16. Attractive piece of information, I had come to know about your blog from my friend arjun, ahmedabad,i have read at least eleven posts of yours by now, and let me tell you, your website gives the best and the most interesting information. This is just the kind of information that i had been looking for, I’m already your rss reader now and I would regularly watch out for the new posts, once again hats off to you! Thanks a lot once again, Regards,
    Sunny Jism 2 Movie review

  17. High achievement...liked the movie suggestions. See celluloidofkewl blog

  18. :D , Terima kasih buat tipsnya, sangat bermanfaat

  19. Another great review Dave. I've heard of this for a long time, but have never sought it out. It sounds right up my alley, so I'll have to make sure I watch it in preparation for any best of the decade lists.